Menu
celery Victor — San Francisco, United States
Photo: Katje Sabin from Chicago, IL, USA — CC BY 2.0

Version from San Francisco, United States

celery Victor — San Francisco, United States

A chilled celery salad from San Francisco: celery hearts poached in stock, marinated, and served with pimento and a light dressing, as served at the St. Francis Hotel.

20 min
Prep
20 min
Cook
4
Servings
Easy
Difficulty
Celery Victor is a chilled celery salad served as a first course rather than a side dish: hearts of celery are cooked until tender, then cooled and left to steep in a savory marinade before being plated over lettuce leaves and finished with a light dressing. The dish is reported from San Francisco and is credited to Victor Hirtzler, head chef at the St. Francis Hotel, around 1910; he is also linked to Crab Louie, another San Francisco dish. The recipe reached a wider audience after writer Clarence Edwords included it in his 1914 guide to the city's restaurants, and it has stayed on the menus of American hotel dining rooms since. To prepare it, whole celery hearts are trimmed of their tougher outer stalks and simmered gently in a veal, chicken, or beef stock until just tender, then cooled in their own broth. Once chilled, the hearts are laid on lettuce and dressed with a marinade built from oil, vinegar or citrus juice, salt, and pepper. Strips of mild red pepper, or pimento, are typically arranged over the top, and some kitchens add a fillet of anchovy or a scattering of chopped tarragon. What distinguishes this dish within the wider family of celery salads is the poaching step: rather than serving the stalks raw and crisp, they are cooked until soft and left to absorb the stock and marinade, giving a texture closer to a cooked vegetable dish served cold than a crunchy salad. The stock-based cooking liquid is also often reduced and used to enrich the marinade itself.

Preparation

  1. Trim the celery hearts of their tougher outer stalks, keeping the tender inner ribs intact.

  2. Simmer the celery hearts in the stock for 15–20 minutes until tender but not falling apart.

  3. Lift the celery hearts from the stock and let them cool completely in a shallow dish.

  4. Whisk together the olive oil, vinegar, lemon juice, salt, and pepper to make the marinade.

  5. Pour the marinade over the cooled celery and refrigerate for at least 2 hours, turning once.

  6. Arrange a bed of lettuce leaves on each plate.

  7. Lift the celery hearts from the marinade and place them on the lettuce.

  8. Top with strips of pimento and, if using, a fillet of anchovy, then spoon over a little marinade.

More recipes from United States

All recipes from United States